What I always thought would blow one's mind would be a centaur or mermaid that turned into a wolf. Far too often it's only the humans who get turned into other things. Fairies, pixies, centaurs, etc., are people too, and can be just as easily transformed. Hooray for change of pace!!
I give you +1500 XP for skill and originality. Hopefully it'll be enough to give you a level up. You deserve it.